Skip to main content

Meloni stresses hostage release, Hamas exclusion in Palestinian state debate

1 min Bruno Finel

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said Tuesday that she is not opposed to the recognition of a Palestinian state, but only under two conditions: the release of hostages held by Hamas and the exclusion of the Islamist movement from any future Palestinian government.

Giorgia Meloni © Mena Today 

Giorgia Meloni © Mena Today 

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said Tuesday that she is not opposed to the recognition of a Palestinian state, but only under two conditions: the release of hostages held by Hamas and the exclusion of the Islamist movement from any future Palestinian government.

“I am not opposed to the recognition of Palestine, but we must establish priorities,” Meloni told Italian media in New York, where she is scheduled to address the UN General Assembly on Wednesday.

According to her remarks broadcast in Italy, the ruling majority will present a motion stating that recognition of Palestine should be tied to those two conditions. 

“Personally, I continue to believe that recognizing Palestine without a state that actually has the attributes of sovereignty neither solves the problem nor produces tangible results for Palestinians,” she added.

Her statement comes just a day after France and several other countries formally recognized the State of Palestine from the UN podium, in what analysts widely see as a symbolic move with limited immediate impact.

French President Emmanuel Macron was at the forefront of this diplomatic campaign, pressing as many states as possible to join the initiative. 

But critics argue the effort has less to do with advancing peace in the Middle East and more to do with reviving Macron’s fading political stature at home.

With his approval ratings at historic lows, Macron appears to be seizing Palestine as a new cause—an act some view as diplomatic marketing rather than genuine strategy. 

While the recognition makes headlines, it does not address fundamental issues such as governance, security, or Hamas’s role, leaving many to question whether this is anything more than symbolism designed to polish a tarnished presidency.

Bruno Finel

Bruno Finel

Bruno Finel is the editor-in-chief of Mena Today. He has extensive experience in the Middle East and North Africa, with several decades of reporting on current affairs in the region.

Related

Diplomacy

Sánchez plays the rebel - Nobody's impressed

Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez told lawmakers Wednesday that the current Middle East conflict is "far worse" than the Iraq War of 2003, a dramatic claim that says more about his domestic political calculations than any genuine diplomatic insight.

Turkey

Erdogan seeks mediator role

Turkey "is playing a role passing messages" between Iran and the U.S. to encourage de-escalation and direct negotiations, Harun Armagan, vice chair of foreign affairs for President Tayyip Erdogan's ruling party, told Reuters on Wednesday. 

Iran at war

Iran's military shuts down Trump's talks

Israel and Iran exchanged airstrikes on Wednesday, as Iran's military rejected President Donald Trump's assertion the U.S. was in negotiations to end the war which has roiled energy and financial markets, saying the U.S. is negotiating with itself.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Mena banner 4

To make this website run properly and to improve your experience, we use cookies. For more detailed information, please check our Cookie Policy.

  • Necessary cookies enable core functionality. The website cannot function properly without these cookies, and can only be disabled by changing your browser preferences.