Skip to main content

The UN report on Israel: Activism masquerading as accountability

1 min Bruno Finel

The United Nations has added Israeli security forces to its annual blacklist of parties suspected of committing sexual violence in conflict zones, a move that has drawn sharp criticism over the organization's deeply entrenched hostility toward the Jewish state.

The UN's obsession with Israel is not new © Mena Today 

The UN's obsession with Israel is not new © Mena Today 

The United Nations has added Israeli security forces to its annual blacklist of parties suspected of committing sexual violence in conflict zones, a move that has drawn sharp criticism over the organization's deeply entrenched hostility toward the Jewish state.

The report, based largely on accusations from detainees, was compiled despite what Israel describes as an open invitation to UN inspectors, who, according to Israeli officials, "chose not to come" and instead "chose to continue with the campaign against Israel."

That detail alone speaks volumes about an organization whose credibility on matters concerning Israel has long been in tatters.

A Vendetta Disguised as Accountability

The UN's obsession with Israel is not new. But since the October 7 Hamas massacres, the deadliest attack on Jews since the Holocaust, it has reached new heights of bad faith. Rather than unequivocally condemning one of the most barbaric terrorist attacks in modern history, the UN has consistently redirected its fire at Israel's military response.

And the organization continues to pay Francesca Albanese, its Special Rapporteur on the Palestinian territories, whose statements have repeatedly crossed the line into what many observers, including prominent Jewish organizations and several Western governments, have denounced as barely veiled antisemitism. Albanese has compared Israeli actions to Nazi crimes and questioned whether October 7 victims deserved sympathy. She remains on the UN payroll.

The blacklist itself raises serious questions. It purports to document "systematic" sexual violence, yet it relies heavily on accounts that cannot be independently verified, given what the UN itself acknowledges are significant access limitations. Israel is lumped alongside regimes in Sudan, Myanmar, and the DRC, where documented atrocities are on an entirely different scale.

The pattern is clear: an institution that was once a pillar of international law has allowed itself to become a platform for anti-Israel activism, shielded by the language of human rights.

Until the UN addresses its own institutional biases, starting by ending its association with figures like Albanese, its reports on Israel will continue to be viewed by many as political documents, not credible accountability mechanisms.

Bruno Finel

Bruno Finel

Bruno Finel is the editor-in-chief of Mena Today. He has extensive experience in the Middle East and North Africa, with several decades of reporting on current affairs in the region.

Related

Hezbollah

Hezbollah turns on Aoun over Lebanon-Israel negotiations

Hezbollah lawmaker Hassan Fadlallah told parliament Thursday that the "ill-fated" framework agreement signed on June 26 between Lebanon and Israel was "doomed to fail," insisting "the Zionists will not be able to impose its implementation" and that "our people will thwart its effects on the ground."

Israel

Vance says some in Israel opposed US Iran deal

U.S. Vice President JD Vance said some members of the Israeli government had tried to influence U.S. public opinion to oppose a deal by the U.S. to end the war with Iran, in a podcast episode with host Joe Rogan posted on Wednesday.

Turkey

Turkey-Qatar axis poses "Significant strategic threat"

A former senior Mossad official is warning that Turkey has outgrown its role as just another regional player, it's now angling to lead the entire Sunni axis, with Qatar as its financial muscle.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Mena banner 4

To make this website run properly and to improve your experience, we use cookies. For more detailed information, please check our Cookie Policy.

  • Necessary cookies enable core functionality. The website cannot function properly without these cookies, and can only be disabled by changing your browser preferences.