Skip to main content

No lasting ceasefire without breaking Hamas’s war machine

1 min Bruno Finel

On Saturday, a Hamas official said the group was prepared to release all remaining hostages held in Gaza in exchange for a five-year truce with Israel. Hamas representatives are currently in Cairo for talks with Egyptian mediators.

The only credible path forward includes the immediate release of all hostages, the disarmament and dismantling of Hamas and Islamic Jihad © Mena Today 

The only credible path forward includes the immediate release of all hostages, the disarmament and dismantling of Hamas and Islamic Jihad © Mena Today 

On Saturday, a Hamas official said the group was prepared to release all remaining hostages held in Gaza in exchange for a five-year truce with Israel. Hamas representatives are currently in Cairo for talks with Egyptian mediators.

While this proposal may sound like a breakthrough, it is unlikely to gain serious traction. Both Israel and Egypt are wary of any arrangement that would allow Hamas to regroup militarily during a prolonged ceasefire. A five-year truce would give Hamas — and Palestinian Islamic Jihad — ample time to rebuild their arsenals, strengthen their networks, and prepare for future rounds of violence.

The reality is clear: lasting peace in Gaza cannot be achieved without the full dismantling of Hamas and Islamic Jihad’s military capabilities. Any agreement that leaves these terrorist organizations intact risks only postponing the next war, not preventing it.

Both Israel and Egypt understand this. Neither is willing to accept a "pause" that would allow terrorist groups to rearm and regain strength. 

The only credible path forward includes the immediate release of all hostages, the disarmament and dismantling of Hamas and Islamic Jihad, and the establishment of a new security framework for Gaza — one led by the Palestinian Authority with strong support from moderate Arab nations.

Stability in Gaza requires more than temporary truces. It demands a fundamental shift: the end of militant rule and the return of governance based on law, security, and the protection of civilian life. Without it, any ceasefire will be fragile — and the cycle of violence will continue.

Bruno Finel

Bruno Finel

Bruno Finel is the editor-in-chief of Mena Today. He has extensive experience in the Middle East and North Africa, with several decades of reporting on current affairs in the region.

Related

Hamas

Israel kills top Hamas commander in Gaza

Israel's military said on Friday it had killed a top Hamas commander in a Gaza airstrike a day earlier, as it presses ahead with a bombing campaign in the Palestinian territory despite U.S.-backed efforts to salvage a 2025 ceasefire.

Lebanon

Israel destroys Hezbollah tunnels at Ali al-Taher ridge

Ali al-Taher, the strategic ridge overlooking Nabatieh, was the site of a fresh Israeli military operation Thursday evening, with the army saying it destroyed "more than two kilometers of Hezbollah underground infrastructure" beneath the height, located north of the Litani River, roughly 15 kilometers from the Israeli border.

Iran

Trump: Iran war will end "Immediately" after November election

President Donald Trump said he expected the war with Iran to end after the November U.S. midterm elections and threatened again to attack a site associated with the Islamic Republic's nuclear programme after the two sides launched their biggest wave of attacks on shipping since the start of the six-month-old war.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Mena banner 4

To make this website run properly and to improve your experience, we use cookies. For more detailed information, please check our Cookie Policy.

  • Necessary cookies enable core functionality. The website cannot function properly without these cookies, and can only be disabled by changing your browser preferences.